Court Orders Care Facility To Pay Attorneys Over OSHA Subpoena

Behavioral health facility failed to comply with OSHA-issued subpoena for documents

By HFT Editorial Staff
January 6, 2022

The Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA) can issue subpoenas to request necessary documents as part of an OSHA inspection. If a recipient fails to comply, the department may then move to enforce the subpoena in federal district court. Recently, a decision by the U.S. District Court for the District of Massachusetts affirmed that recipients who oppose such investigative requests without substantial justification can face significant and costly consequences.

On Oct. 21, 2021, the court ordered UHS of Fuller Inc. and UHS of Delaware Inc. to pay the department $30,515.63 in attorneys’ fees after they failed to comply with an OSHA-issued subpoena for documents. OSHA issued the subpoena as part of a 2019 workplace violence inspection at an Attleboro behavioral health facility the companies operated. Among other things, the subpoena requested video footage of workplace violence incidents involving employees at the facility. After failing to comply, the department’s regional office of the solicitor petitioned the court to enforce the subpoena for the requested video.

The court found that the companies’ opposition was not “substantially justified” and ordered them to comply with the subpoena, and to pay the department’s attorneys’ fees incurred responding to their arguments.

“The court made clear that there can be significant consequences for a recipient that opposes OSHA subpoena compliance without substantial justification. The law makes a clear distinction between good faith arguments and those that lack merit,” said Maia Fisher, OSHA regional solicitor of labor. “If a recipient chooses to engage in the latter, the recipient should expect to be held accountable.”

See the latest posts on our homepage Share

Topic Area: Safety

Recent Posts
Recent Posts

How Can FEMA Help Hospitals Mitigate and Recover from Disaster?

Following disasters, FEMA will reimburse 75-100 percent of costs for services such as debris removal, overtime pay, and infrastructure repairs


WVU Cancer Institute Opens New Center

new 1,400-square-foot clinic will include six new infusion bays


The Role of Employee Feedback in the ‘Great Resignation’

Regularly listening to employee feedback can help employers retain staff


What Will 2022 Bring to Healthcare Facilities?

Telemedicine and supply chain challenges will continue to affect planning, design, and construction


Mask Requirements Continue Evolving in Healthcare

In response to the omicron variant, healthcare facilities adjust mask requirements


Post Comment


News & Updates • Webcast Alerts • Building Technologies

All fields are required.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.