How to Avoid Generator Failure in Hospitals

Address these common generator problems to avoid power downtime

By By Michael Fluegeman and Antonio “Tommy” Tan III

In hospitals and other critical facilities, standby engine generators (code-required emergency and optional) are normally idle and need to quickly and reliably start when utility power fails for more than a few seconds. And they need to run for the duration of the utility outage, and sometimes longer. 

What goes wrong? 

The engine fails to start, the engine starts but switchgear fails to connect the generator to the critical load, or the engine starts, connects and supports the load but fails during operation. 

A less critical but important failure scenario to be aware of, especially for minimally-staffed facilities, is the generator system that does everything it is supposed to do except allow the facility to return to utility power after it has returned and stabilized, and shut itself down. In this case, a standby generator could unnecessarily run all night or all weekend if not effectively monitored by remote staff. And if it is carrying load in this scenario, running out of diesel fuel and other long-run failure risks are a concern. 

Let’s look at the common failure modes and ways to avoid them.

Fail to start. Ensure that the engine or automatic transfer (ATS)/switchgear controls are in automatic mode. Regularly check to be sure that the engine cranking batteries (or battery charger) have not failed and that power to the battery charger is on and has not failed. 

Another potential problem to be aware of is that the ATS may not recognize the utility power failure and therefore not send the engine-start signal. Regular ATS testing, where the normal source to the ATS is turned off, if only for a few seconds to see that the engine begins cranking, will validate this aspect of ATS performance.

Engine runs but fails to connect to critical load. When performing regular preventive maintenance, a technician should confirm that the ATS neutral switch timing setpoint is correct. Regularly check to make sure that the engine main breaker was not left open. To prevent nuisance trips when loaded, adjust the breaker setting so it isn’t at minimum. Perform regular transfer testing (which can be initiated manually at the ATS without opening circuit breakers) to help prevent the following failure modes:

• ATS does not recognize generator power as acceptable.

• ATS jams or otherwise fails to transfer.

• ATS transfers but contacts fail under load.

Engine runs, carries load but fails before utility power returns. To avoid fuel delivery problems or contaminated fuel, regularly check pumps and filters and to be sure fuel is not contaminated. Operate on generator for extended periods (several hours) to confirm extended run performance and help prevent the following failure modes:

• Engine overheats due to coolant/radiator/louver issues, high load, high ambient temperature.

• Engine component, fuel injector or control system failures.

• Engine, voltage regulator or speed governor incompatibility with load (leading power factor, high harmonic current, large block loads, etc.).

Engine continues running indefinitely after stable return of utility power. Check to see if ATS timer/setpoints are correct; they may be set to require manual transfer to normal. Ensure that ATS-in-phase monitor is correctly adjusted and that engine frequency is not too fast or too slow to allow in-phase monitor or closed-transition transfer. Perform regular transfer and re-transfer testing (which can be initiated manually at the ATS without opening circuit breakers) to confirm proper performance and help prevent these failure modes:

• ATS fails to recognize stable return of utility power.

• ATS jams or otherwise fails to transfer.

Michael Fluegeman (, PE, is director of engineering and principal, critical facilities, for PlanNet, an independent professional services firm that provides advisory, design, project management, and construction services supporting critical IT infrastructure.

Antonio “Tommy” Tan III (, PE, is a critical facilities mechanical engineer at PlanNet.

March 29, 2021

Topic Area: Energy and Power

Recent Posts

Creating an Inclusive Space for Everyone Through Universal Design

Designers are using their compassion to create inclusive spaces for all patients.

Lehigh Valley Health Network and Children's Hospital of Philadelphia Announce Affiliation Agreement

The affiliation is to provide optimal care for children in the region.

Four Healthcare Construction Best Practices

Strategies that prove effective can boost efficiency, lower costs and promote long-term success.

Piedmont Henry Hospital to Expand with New Patient Tower

The project is expected to start in early 2024.

Bill Proposed to Make Assaulting Healthcare Workers a Federal Crime

Efforts to reduce workplace violence in healthcare settings are coming from both health organizations and Capitol Hill.


FREE Newsletter Signup Form

News & Updates | Webcast Alerts
Building Technologies | & More!


All fields are required. This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.