Most Rural Hospitals at Risk of Closure

The ongoing labor shortage has contributed to wards shutting down at several hospitals, but what happens when an entire facility closes?

By Mackenna Moralez


The ongoing labor shortage is impacting every single industry, and the hospitals and other healthcare facilities are not exempt from it. Healthcare employees are quitting in record numbers citing burnout, lack of flexibility and poor treatment as reasons to leave. However, hospitals  are now struggling to recruit and retain new talent, resulting in some locations or wards being at risk of shutting down because of lack of staff.  

As Healthcare Facilities Today previously reported, Advocate Aurora Health temporarily closed three urgent care facilities in the Milwaukee area in December due to staffing issues. Also, Indiana’s Pulaski Memorial Hospital closed its OB department in March – an action brought on by the impact of the COVID-19 pandemic and lack of available maternity nurses.  

Meanwhile, long-term care facilities are also hurting from the labor shortage. Since the beginning of the pandemic, employment levels in nursing homes have dropped by 14 percent. In comparison, hospitals have lost just 1.6 percent of employees. According to the report by American Health Care Association and National Center for Assisted Living, 86 percent of nursing homes and 77 percent of assisted living providers have said that their workforce situation has gotten worse in recent months, forcing 58 percent of nursing homes to begin limiting new admissions. In addition, 78 percent of nursing homes and 61 percent of assisted living communities are concerned workforce challenges might force them to close their operations. 

These aren’t the only healthcare facilities at risk of closing. There are over 500 rural hospitals at immediate risk of closure due to financial losses and lack of financial reserves to sustain operations, according to a report by the Center for Healthcare Quality and Price Reform. . Almost every state has at least one rural hospital at immediate risk of closure, and in 21 states, 25 percent or more of the rural hospitals are at risk.  

Nearly all the rural hospitals that are at risk of closing are in isolated rural communities. If closed, community residents would no longer be able to receive emergency or inpatient care without having to travel long distances. Meanwhile, these facilities are often the only place residents can get laboratory tests or imaging studies done.  

The American Hospital Association is urging Congress to address the ongoing staffing shortage in a statement submitted to the Senate Health, Education, Labor & Pensions Committee. In it, the agency discussed the way it is impacting hospitals and health systems, detailing ways the field is supporting its workforce and asking Congress to enact policies to address the issue. 

“Though managing workforce pressures were a challenge for hospitals even before the pandemic, these challenges have only grown more acute,” the statement says. “The incredible physical and emotional toll that hospital workers have endured in caring for patients during the pandemic has, among other issues, exacerbated the shortage of hospital workers. This shortage has become so critical that some states and the federal government have deployed military and National Guard resources to help mitigate staffing challenges at some hospitals. As this shortage has worsened and COVID-19 hospitalizations have reached record levels, labor costs for hospitals have increased dramatically. This combination of factors has been exploited by traveling staffing companies and other firms that provide contract labor resources, driving up workforce slots even more for hospitals. Hospitals also have incurred significant costs in recruiting and retaining staff, which have included overtime pay, bonus pay and other incentives. This is occurring at a time when many hospitals and health systems are still facing other immense financial constraints. For many hospitals around the country, this has led to an unsustainable situation that threatens their ability to care for the patients and communities they serve.” 

Mackenna Moralez is assistant editor with Healthcare Facilities Today. 



March 17, 2022


Topic Area: Industry News , Maintenance and Operations


Recent Posts

How Efficiency Checklists Help Hospitals Save Energy, Water and Money

Keith Edgerton explains how a simple, systematic tool can help healthcare facilities identify savings, support sustainability goals and reinvest in long-term decarbonization.


Designing with Heart: Seen Health Center Blends Cultural Warmth and Clinical Care

Case study: The Alhambra-based facility uses Wilsonart Woodgrains to create a space where comfort, tradition and durability come together for an elevated senior care experience.


Rutgers Health and University Hospital Breaks Ground on Campus Expansion

The groundbreaking follows the long-awaited demolition of administrative offices built in the 1970s.


What to Consider When Modernizing Healthcare Facilities

While there has been a call to preserve old buildings, healthcare facilities need to weigh the options of patient care.


Corewell Health Beaumont Troy Hospital to Build New Tower

The tower is expected to be completed in 2030.


 
 


FREE Newsletter Signup Form

News & Updates | Webcast Alerts
Building Technologies | & More!

 
 
 


All fields are required. This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.